Hidden Meadows Coops for Sale
A coop community in Middle Island, Suffolk County — tracked building by building: live listings, what units actually sell for, carrying costs, and what its board expects from buyers.
What is Hidden Meadows?
Hidden Meadows is a coop development in Middle Island, Suffolk County.
About this building
- Built
- 1970
- Style
- Garden
- Typical unit
- 700 sq ft
- Typical maintenance
- $870/mo
- Pets
- Cats OK, No Dogs
- Laundry
- Common Area
- Subletting
- Allowed
- Stories
- 2
- Basement
- No
- Garage
- No
- Flip tax
- No
- Board approval
- Yes
- Income floor
- $60,000
- Heating
- Forced Air, Natural Gas
- Cooling
- Central Air
Amenities
Maintenance includes
Compiled from 19 recorded listings in this development. Building details can change — confirm with the managing agent.
Counts and medians cover coops inside Hidden Meadows specifically, measured from OneKey MLS records as of October 2026. Medians are rounded — individual units vary by line, floor, and condition.
What home styles does Hidden Meadows offer?
Compiled from OneKey MLS records of coop sales and listings inside Hidden Meadows over the past 24 months — layouts the building actually trades, not an official floor-plan list. Medians rounded and shown only with 5+ sales.
What is for sale in Hidden Meadows right now?
What have Hidden Meadows coops actually sold for?
14 units closed here over the past 24 months (12 in the last 12), with a 12-month median sale price around $190K and a typical 54 days to contract. We publish building-level aggregates here. The unit-by-unit sale history — which lines sold, at what price per room, and how each was marketed — we send on request.
The sale history covers the whole Middle Island development. A valuation prices one specific unit — use it if you own here.
What does it take to buy in Hidden Meadows?
Buying here runs through the building itself: a board package documenting your finances and references, then a board interview. What this board actually requires — minimum down payment, debt-to-income, reserves after closing, sublet and pet rules — is specific to Hidden Meadows and can be stricter than your lender’s guidelines. We confirm the current requirements directly with the managing agent before you offer, so you never learn them from a rejection.
Requirements are set by the building and change over time — always confirm the current rules with the managing agent before you offer. General information, not legal advice.
Where is Hidden Meadows — and what else is nearby?
The red marker is Hidden Meadows; dark markers are the other coop and condo developments we track in Suffolk County — click any of them to open that building’s market page.
Commuting from Hidden Meadows
Train times are typical scheduled rides; check the MTA for current schedules.
Comparing Hidden Meadows to nearby coop developments
Ordered by distance from Hidden Meadows — same-town neighbours first, then nearest. The numbers are positions in that order, not a ranking, and each development’s own figures are shown so the comparison is like for like.
-
1
North Isle Village Coram · 3.8 mi away42 sold / 12 mo 13 for sale now $199K median ask 49 median days
-
2
Village in the Woods Selden · 4.9 mi away13 sold / 12 mo 3 for sale now $250K median ask 15 median days
-
3
Stony Hollow Port Jefferson Station · 7.2 mi away17 sold / 12 mo 8 for sale now $194K median ask 42 median days
-
4
Birchwood Glen Holtsville · 8.8 mi away19 sold / 12 mo 3 for sale now $350K median ask 22 median days
Get a feel for the Middle Island area
Middle Island Coop Questions, Answered
What is the coop board approval process in Middle Island?
After a signed contract, the buyer submits a board package — typically a financial statement, tax returns, bank statements, reference letters, and the purchase application — followed by a board interview. Boards can decline without stating a reason (subject to fair-housing and other anti-discrimination laws). Timelines vary by building. A well-prepared package is the single biggest thing a buyer controls.
What happens at a coop board interview, and how should I prepare?
Most boards interview after reviewing your financial package — usually a short in-person or video meeting with a handful of board members. Expect questions about your finances, why you want to live in the building, and how you'll use the apartment; boards are gauging fit as much as qualification, and they cannot legally ask about protected categories like family status, religion, or national origin. The best preparation is a clean, complete board package beforehand — interviews go smoothly when there's nothing left for the board to ask about.
What does coop maintenance actually cover?
Maintenance is your monthly payment to the coop corporation, and it is one bill covering several things at once: the building's property taxes, your share of the underlying mortgage if the building carries one, staff and day-to-day operations, insurance, and contributions to reserves. Because the property taxes sit inside it, a portion of your maintenance is typically tax-deductible — your accountant can tell you which portion for a given building. The current maintenance figure appears on every coop listing we show. One note if you are comparing against condos: a condo's common charges exclude taxes and any underlying mortgage, so a coop maintenance figure will look higher for the same apartment without actually costing more.
How much do I need to put down on a coop?
Each coop building sets its own minimum, and it is a building rule rather than a lender rule — so it applies even to a buyer a bank would happily approve. Of the 997 co-op corporations whose minimum down payment we have confirmed from MLS listings, 75% require 20%, 16% allow 10%, and 8% require 25% or more. Some also require post-closing liquidity — months of mortgage and maintenance held in reserve after closing — on top of the down payment. We publish the confirmed minimum on the building pages where we can verify it, and confirm it listing by listing otherwise.
What debt-to-income ratio do coop boards look for?
Many boards set a maximum share of your gross income that your total housing costs and debt payments may take up. The threshold, and how strictly it's enforced, is set by each building. It's a board policy, not a lender requirement, and it's worth checking before you fall for a unit that a particular building's math won't support.
What is a post-closing liquidity requirement?
Some coop boards require you to keep a set amount of cash or liquid assets, measured in months of mortgage and maintenance payments, in reserve after your closing costs and down payment are paid, as proof you can weather a job loss or emergency without falling behind. It's on top of the down payment, not part of it, and requirements vary widely by building.
What is a sponsor unit, and can I buy a coop without board approval?
A sponsor unit is an apartment still owned by the entity that originally converted the building to a coop, rather than by an individual shareholder. Sponsor sales commonly skip the financial-package-and-interview process a resale requires, though the sponsor may still have its own approval or financing conditions, and house rules like sublet limits still apply once you own it. Sponsor units are worth asking about specifically if board approval is your biggest concern.
How can I check a coop building's finances before buying?
The board package process gives you access to the building's financial statements, board meeting minutes, reserve fund balance, and any pending assessments or litigation — an accountant or attorney can spot warning signs like thin reserves, rising underlying debt, or deferred maintenance that a listing description won't mention. This is exactly where having an attorney's eye on your deal from the start pays off, rather than discovering an issue after you're under contract.
What is a flip tax and who pays it?
A flip tax is a transfer fee charged by the coop corporation when a unit sells — commonly a percentage of the sale price or a per-share amount. Who pays it is set by the building's rules and the contract, and it varies by building. It belongs in any serious net-proceeds estimate, which is why our seller conversations start with the building's actual rules.
Can I sublet a coop apartment?
Only if the building allows it. Sublet policies range from prohibited, to allowed after a minimum period of owner occupancy, to allowed with board approval and fees. If rental flexibility matters to you, the proprietary lease and house rules need to be checked before you make an offer — not after.
Why are coop monthly charges higher than condo common charges?
Coop maintenance usually bundles the building's underlying mortgage and property taxes along with operations — condo owners pay property taxes separately. So a coop's higher monthly number is not automatically a worse deal; part of it may also be tax-deductible. Comparing a coop and condo fairly means comparing the all-in monthly cost, which we break down for every listing we work on.

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID.
Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of October 10, 2026 8:45 pm. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.
Personal-use terms and which listings this site shows: MLS & Data Disclosures
The DeVito Team of Keller Williams Realty Greater Nassau
Joseph DeVito, NY Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
400 Garden City Plaza Ste 438, Garden City, NY 11530 · (516) 770-3782
